If you didn't watch and you have somehow avoided the media deluge, you may not know that Adam Lambert (the one on the left) was supposed to win this contest. From basically the moment of his audition, the judges had crowned him the victor. It was sometimes more than a little annoying that they assumed all of America would make him the winner because they thought he should be. Most Americans, most people, don't like to be told how to think or what to do. It's the nature of the beast.
Both of these guys are incredibly talented. Adam is the consummate entertainer, always willing to take a risk to make his song an event more than a performance. He has a range that would make Mariah Carey proud, even if he may have a tendency to utilize it more often than necessary. Kris is a musician. He can sit down and jam on the piano, guitar or rely solely on the homey flavor of his voice to relate to his audience. He has a quirky way of scooting his jaw to the right when he hits certain notes, but it's more endearing than annoying. Again, both really great performers.
I believe that Kris won this contest because on the night of the finale the judges were basically consoling him for his inevitable loss to the great and powerful Adam, whom America simply had to crown king. Americans are notorious for loving the underdog, and I think particularly Kara, Paula and Simon catapulted him to that status, setting him up for a huge upset win.
But what shocked me about this was not the fact that Kris won. He was equally deserving of the trophy. It was not Adam's reaction, because he was as gracious as anyone could be and seemed genuinely happy for Kris. (Of course, he has nothing to be sad about. I'm sure the wolves were waiting outside his dressing room door with drool matting their silk shirts in a complete frenzy to be the first to consume this prey.)
What was unsettling was the reaction I saw on Facebook after the results were announced. People were genuinely angry that Adam lost. I guess that's not all that unusual, because we do get passionate about all kinds of ultimately meaningless things... but we're not doing football confessions in this post.
But I was reading things like "the idiocy of the American public...", "prejudice and ignorance equal injustice...", and even "I was hoping personal preference wouldn't decide the winner this year." Excuse me? Isn't personal preference what causes someone to vote one way or the other? That one didn't make any sense.
The prejudice remark refers to the fact that Adam Lambert is rumored to be gay. I honestly can't verify this because I haven't done any research. But it was definitely out there early on that he is. So there are all these articles out there saying that conservatives and evangelicals pushed Kris over the top because we hate gay people. Get serious. First of all, in the overall viewing audience of American Idol, how many do you suppose are conservative evangelical? I'm just saying...
I couldn't resist arguing with the person who posted his anger over prejudice and ignorance equaling injustice. I asked him if he was seriously saying that everyone who voted for Kris was an ignorant bigot. Assuming that homophobia played a part in all of Kris's support is to display exactly the same kind of prejudice that he was complaining about.
I'm so sick of being blamed for my choices based on labeling. I'm homophobic because I preferred Kris. I'm racist because I preferred John McCain (albeit slightly) to Barack Obama. Can't possibly be because I thought Kris was a better musician or completely disagreed with all of Obama's policies. This makes me crazy.
Labeling has gotten out of control. I call you a tree-hugger because you use reusable grocery bags. You call me an enemy of the environment because I drive a minivan. Even though I recycle and you probably take an airplane when you go on long trips, even though our similarities are perhaps even greater than our differences, we both get labeled and judged accordingly.
This pattern is going to continue in the world. This country is becoming more and more divisive each day. The only way to make a difference is to begin with unity in the body of Christ. We are united by a lot of common ground. If we could focus on those things that unite us instead of getting hung up on the lesser details, I think the impact could be great.
My friend Kristen always quotes St. Augustine, and I love it. In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity.
Let's love instead of label. It would make the world a better place.